Celebrating 27 Years!

BuyMeToys.Com Exclusives

BuyMeToys.Com Exclusives

The BuyMeToys Buzz

Keep up to date on everything about the store and our website. Exclusive info about sales, signings & other events.

Our Blog

Hot Books or Hot on the Horizon

Current or Upcoming Comics that are sure to be in demand. Order these comics now to make sure you don't miss out.

Popular Comics

Out of the BuyMeToys Vault

Comics and Merchandise we have pulled out of the BuyMeToys.Com warehouse. New store inventory and collections we have bought over the years.

Vintage Products

Featured collection

  • ThunderCats #1 Buy Me Toys & Comics Exclusive Set
    Buy Me Toys & Comics Exclusive Virgin Cover
    Vendor
    Dynamite Comics
    Regular price
    $19.99
    Sale price
    $19.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • ThunderCats #1 Buy Me Toys & Comics Exclusive
    Vendor
    Dynamite Comics
    Regular price
    $12.99
    Sale price
    $12.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ghost Machine (One-Shot) Buy Me Toys & Comics Exclusive
    Vendor
    BUYMETOYS.COM
    Regular price
    $12.99
    Sale price
    $12.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Svengoolie Lost in Time #1 Buy Me Toys & Comics Exclusive
    Vendor
    BUYMETOYS.COM
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • FUTURE STATE THE NEXT BATMAN #1 BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive Team Variant
    Vendor
    DC COMICS
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Sale price
    $13.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • BATMAN CATWOMAN #1 BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive Team Variant
    Vendor
    DC COMICS
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Sale price
    $13.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • PUNCHLINE SPECIAL #1 BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive Team Variant
    Vendor
    DC COMICS
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Sale price
    $13.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • YEAR OF THE VILLAIN #1
    Vendor
    DC COMICS
    Regular price
    $1.00
    Sale price
    $1.00
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • BATMAN #100 BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive Team Variant
    Vendor
    DC COMICS
    Regular price
    $13.99
    Sale price
    $13.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Charlie Brown BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive F.E.P. Figure
    Vendor
    Round 2
    Regular price
    $14.99
    Sale price
    $14.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Skinny Santa and Baby Rudolph BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive F.E.P. Figure
    Vendor
    Round 2
    Regular price
    $14.99
    Sale price
    $14.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Tales From The Dark Multiverse: Batman & Superman Ultimate BuyMeToys.Com Exclusive Set
    Vendor
    DC Comics
    Regular price
    $48.99
    Sale price
    $48.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Sold out

BuyMeToys.Com

Est. 1996

Michiana's Source for Comics, Statues, Action Figures and More

Family Owned and Operated

The best comic and collectibles shop in the midwest.

Mike Thompson

Fantastic service and a very welcoming atmosphere. Casey and Kelly are super friendly and knowledgeable. This is quite simply the best comic stop around!

Richard Calvert

This is the best comic store I have ever been in!

Scott M. Bradley